Why Your Bathroom Smells Musty—Could It Be a Tap Seal?

Noticing a musty smell every time you walk into your bathroom—even after it’s been cleaned? You’re not alone, and the culprit might be something surprisingly small: a worn or faulty tap seal. This article unpacks how this overlooked plumbing part can lead to lingering odors, what signs to look for, and how to fix the issue—whether you’re a handy DIYer or need expert help.

Here’s what we’ll cover:

• That Musty Bathroom Smell—What’s Going On?
• What Is a Tap Seal and Why Does It Matter?
• Signs Your Tap Seal Might Be the Culprit
• DIY or Call the Pros? Here’s What to Do Next
• Final Takeaway—Don’t Let a Small Seal Create a Big Stink

Let’s start by looking at what might really be behind that unpleasant bathroom odor.

That Musty Bathroom Smell—What’s Going On?

Why does my bathroom smell musty?

If you’ve cleaned your bathroom top to bottom but that damp, musty smell just won’t go away, you’re not imagining things—and it’s not just lingering air freshener residue. Bathrooms are naturally humid spaces, especially during Sydney’s wetter months or in homes without great ventilation. But when that musty scent sticks around, even after a deep clean, it could be a sign of something deeper within your plumbing.

Common culprits include trapped moisture behind walls, slow leaks, or clogged drains where organic matter builds up. But one lesser-known source often flies under the radar: a faulty tap seal. When the rubber washer or O-ring inside your tap fitting begins to deteriorate, it can allow small amounts of water to seep out—just enough to create hidden dampness. That moisture, over time, leads to mold growth or bacterial buildup, which is what your nose is picking up. 

Why it matters and when to act

That smell isn’t just unpleasant—it’s your bathroom trying to tell you something. Persistent moisture around fittings or behind tiles can lead to mold, mildew, and even structural damage if left unchecked. In some cases, we’ve seen homes in the Inner West where a minor leak from a worn tap seal caused water to soak into cabinetry or wall cavities, leading to costly repairs months later.

While the issue might seem minor, ignoring it can create bigger headaches down the track. Musty odors are often one of the first warning signs that something’s off behind the scenes in your bathroom plumbing. You may also start to see indicators of structural damage that homeowners often overlook until it’s too late.

Key takeaway: If your bathroom smells moldy despite being clean, don’t overlook the possibility of a failing tap seal. It’s a small part that can create a surprisingly big stink.

What Is a Tap Seal and Why Does It Matter?

A simple breakdown for non-plumbers

A tap seal is a small but essential part of your bathroom plumbing that helps keep water exactly where it’s supposed to be—inside your pipes. If you’ve ever noticed a slow drip from a tap even when it’s fully turned off, chances are the tap seal is to blame.

In most modern taps, this seal is made up of a rubber washer, O-ring, or faucet gasket that sits inside the tap fitting or at the base of a compression joint. Its job? To create a tight seal between moving parts when the tap is closed, preventing any water from leaking through.

Think of it like a rubber plug inside the mechanism—every time you turn the handle, it compresses to block the water flow. Over time, though, even the best seals wear down or shift out of place, especially with heavy use or poor installation. You’ll find these seals in almost every type of bathroom tap, from classic pillar taps to mixer styles. And while they’re tucked away out of sight, when they start to fail, they don’t stay quiet for long

What happens when a tap seal fails

When a tap seal goes bad, it might not make a big splash—literally. The early signs are usually subtle: a slow drip, a small puddle around the base of the tap, or that musty smell we covered earlier. But what’s happening behind the scenes can have bigger consequences.

Here are the most common reasons tap seals stop doing their job:

• Age and wear – Rubber parts naturally degrade over time, especially in Sydney’s variable climate where hot water, humidity, and minerals in the water supply take a toll.
  
• Poor installation – If the seal wasn’t seated properly or the wrong size was used, it can fail prematurely.
  
• Over-tightening – Cranking the tap too hard when turning it off can flatten or crack the washer, causing leaks.
  

When the tap isn’t sealing properly, even small amounts of water can seep out consistently.

This leads to:

• Water leakage around tap fixtures
  
• Mildew or mold growth in and around cabinetry
  
• Persistent musty odors due to hidden dampness

So while a leaking tap might seem minor, it can quietly contribute to bigger plumbing and hygiene issues over time.

Key takeaway: A working tap seal keeps your plumbing watertight and your bathroom smelling fresh. When it fails, even a trickle can lead to mold, mustiness, and long-term damage—so it’s worth knowing what’s going on inside your tap.

Signs Your Tap Seal Might Be the Culprit

Physical and smell-based signs to check

You don’t need to be a plumber to spot the signs of a failing tap seal. In fact, your nose might notice the issue before your eyes do. 

Here’s a practical checklist of things to look (and sniff) for around your bathroom taps:

• A constant drip, even when the tap is fully closed
  This is one of the clearest indicators that the tap seal isn’t sealing properly. Even small, regular drips add up to water waste—and signal that the rubber washer or O-ring might be worn out.
  
• That “wet towel” or moldy smell near your sink
  If your bathroom smells musty or you catch a bad smell from the bathroom sink, the issue may be moisture pooling around the tap base or seeping into cabinetry below. It’s often caused by a slow leak that never dries out.
  
• Water stains, rust, or visible dampness around the tap
  Take a close look at where your tap meets the basin or countertop. Any bubbling paint, soft timber, or dark marks may point to hidden plumbing smells from bathroom areas—likely from ongoing leaks.
  
• Mildew or mold growth on or near the tap
  Mould thrives in damp, dark corners. If you’re constantly wiping away mildew near your basin with no clear cause, it’s worth checking the tap fitting more closely.
  
• Higher-than-usual water bills
  While less obvious, a subtle, constant leak from a tap seal can lead to a noticeable jump in your usage over time. You can try some leak detection tips from Sydney Water to catch sneaky water waste early.
  
• Loose or wobbly tap fittings
  A shifting tap may be putting pressure on the seal, causing it to degrade or dislodge—leading to leaks and water ingress.
  

If you’re trying to figure out how to tell if your tap is leaking, start with your senses: sight, smell, and touch. Spotting these early signs means you can take action before things escalate into serious water damage.

Key takeaway: A worn tap seal doesn’t always make a scene—but signs like a dripping tap, musty smell, or damp marks around the basin are your bathroom’s way of waving a red flag. Catch it early, and you’ll save yourself from bigger plumbing headaches down the line.

DIY or Call the Pros? Here’s What to Do Next

What you can try at home

If you’ve noticed a drip, dampness, or a musty smell around your tap, there are a few simple steps you can take before calling in a professional. With a bit of patience and a few basic tools, you might be able to fix a leaky tap seal yourself.

Here’s what to try:

• Inspect the tap fitting
  Check around the base of the tap for signs of looseness, corrosion, or water pooling. Gently wiggle the tap—if it feels unstable, that could be putting pressure on the seal.
  
• Turn off the water and open the tap
  Always start by shutting off the water supply. Then open the tap fully to release any pressure in the line.
  
• Remove the tap handle and access the seal
  Most tap handles can be unscrewed to reveal the internal mechanism. You’ll typically find a rubber washer or O-ring seated inside the compression joint. These are the key components of the tap seal.
  
• Replace the worn part
  While less obvious, a subtle, constant leak from a tap seal can lead to a noticeable jump in your usage over time.
  
• Test for leaks
  Once the tap is back together, turn the water back on slowly and check for drips.
  

For many Sydney homeowners, replacing a tap washer is a satisfying and inexpensive fix that can stop both leaks and that annoying bathroom smell. But it’s not always that straightforward.

When to call in a plumber

Sometimes, a leaky tap is just the tip of the iceberg. If you’ve tried a quick fix and the problem keeps coming back—or you’re not comfortable opening up your tap assembly—it’s best to call in a licensed plumber.

Here’s when to get professional help:

• The leak isn’t isolated to one tap
  If you’re seeing similar signs in multiple bathrooms or fixtures, the issue might be deeper in your plumbing system.
  
• There’s no visible leak, but the smell persists
  This could suggest a hidden leak behind the wall or under the vanity—hard to detect without the right tools.
  
• You notice mold, soft cabinetry, or discolouration
  Water damage doesn’t take long to set in. If there’s any sign that moisture has spread, it’s time to act quickly.
  
• You’ve tried replacing the washer and it didn’t help
  Not all plumbing seals are created equal—some issues require reseating, new fittings, or professional sealing.
  

Not sure what’s going on? We’re happy to take a look—no pressure. Whether it’s a persistent smell, a mystery leak, or just peace of mind, our team can help you get to the bottom of it. Explore our Bathroom Plumbing and Bathroom Renovation services.

Key takeaway: Basic fixes like a washer swap can work wonders—but if the issue runs deeper or you’re unsure where to start, don’t wait for the smell to turn into serious damage. A quick visit from a local plumber can save you time, stress, and costly repairs later.

Final Takeaway—Don’t Let a Small Seal Create a Big Stink

It’s easy to overlook something as small as a tap seal, but as you’ve seen, even a tiny failure in this part can lead to persistent bathroom odors, hidden leaks, and long-term water damage. What starts as a faint musty smell near the sink can quickly snowball into mold growth, warped cabinetry, or costly repairs—especially if left unchecked.

The good news? Catching and addressing a worn or faulty seal early is simple and often inexpensive, whether you tackle it yourself or bring in a professional. Knowing the signs and acting sooner rather than later is the best way to protect your bathroom and your peace of mind.

Still noticing that musty smell? Let us help pinpoint the problem.Our team at In House Plumbing is here to make it easy—whether that means confirming a leak, replacing a faulty washer, or ensuring your bathroom is watertight and worry-free.

Frequently Asked Questions